The other day, a company emailed me (and a bunch of other bloggers) to promote their weight loss product. I am not going to get into details on what this product is or who the company is because I am not interested in slandering anyone. We all have to make a living, I guess. But there were a few things about the initial email as well as the response to my reply that really irked me.
The initial email said that this company was writing to me because of my blog’s focus on weight loss. Right away, I knew that this company did not actually READ my blog. When have I ever talked about weight loss (aside from recounting my personal weight experiences in relation to my gastrointestinal issue)? Yes, I promote a healthy lifestyle and express my thoughts on health. Yes, I love exercising and I discuss my workouts in great detail. But eating healthfully and working out are part of living a healthy lifestyle for me — and should be for everyone. I don’t ever discuss tips on losing weight, aside from expressing to the best of my ability that if you eat clean, real, whole foods I strongly believe your weight will stabilize. Notice I said stabilize — NOT lose. I never discuss calories unless it is part of a product review. I don’t count calories and honestly, you wouldn’t want me to discuss my own caloric intake because I have a tendency to round everything up to the nearest 500. And worrying about calories isn’t really necessary if you’re eating vegetables, fruits, sprouted grains (or high quality whole grains, but check the ingredient list), nuts, non-factory meat, real eggs (from happy, free chickens), small amounts of real butter, milk (if you can tolerate it), and on and on. Eat cleanly and it will all work out.
(Which reminds me, I still need to discuss the books In Defense of Food and Real Food and I just got The Omnivore’s Dilemma. I will probably do a summary post of all three when I finish Omnivore’s.)
Okay, so maybe she assumed a blog largely about health and fitness must be about weight loss if it was written by a girl. Or maybe that all readers of these blogs are trying to lose weight. Some are — and good for them! I am all for being as healthy and in shape as you can be. But still . . . at least read my blog if you want me to promote your product.
So I responded with a nice note, thanking her for the offer and explaining that I try to avoid processed foods containing GMO soy and corn (their product was processed and contained these things) and that I try to educate my readers in this as well (again, if they read my blog, they would know this). I further expressed my thoughts on eating cleanly to stabilize weight rather than relying on a product. I said it nicely and concisely.
Aside:Â Has any “weight loss product” truly helped anyone long term? Maybe, but generally no, as the diet trends and fads come and go. And any tool that means putting more chemically processed junk into your body cannot be a tool you’d want to rely on for very long. Unless you are a fan of cancer.
After my response, I thought all was done. Wrong!
The woman from the company replied back and said:
“I understand that you don’t feel that our product is a tool you can use in your weight loss program, but if you change your mind please let me know.”
And herein lies the source of my anger. The reason I am even writing about this at all, because if it had been left with my last email I wouldn’t have ever thought about it again or put it on this blog. But this, this one line, got me angry:
My weight loss program.
Why would she think I am on a weight loss program? I’m not going to tell you my weight on here, but let’s just say I am a fairly thin girl with a very small frame and I should not be on any weight loss program if I want to be healthy. Me going on a weight loss program would likely be considered an eating disorder.
A more appropriate response to me would have been “I understand that you don’t feel that our product is a tool you can feel comfortable sharing with your readers . . .” That would have been fine. But. My weight loss program? Is it because I am a girl, I must be on a diet? Or because I work out and no girl ever works out unless they are trying to lose weight? Or because I try my best to eat healthfully and no girl would ever choose carob over chocolate unless she was trying to drop some pounds? (Note: Carob satisfies the chocolate cravings. Try it — in its unsweetened form if you can! With none of the chemical aftertaste of M&Ms.)
I know, I know. I am overreacting. It just bothered me. It bothered me that the marketing company for a product that promises weight loss through sketchy methods would assume I am on a weight loss program. It bothered me that they are blindly throwing their product out there without checking who they are relying on to promote it. You’d think they would at least read up on who they contact to make sure values align, etc. What if I liked murder and wrote my blog about murder and weight loss? Would they have still contacted me to promote their product? Probably. Although you can probably safely assume that any company that makes a quick weight loss fake ingredient GMO product designed to “trick” your body wouldn’t exactly have the most ethical standards.
And our bodies do not need to be tricked; that is in fact what processed foods and imitation “low-fat” labeled foods have been doing to them for years. And what did that do for us? Cancer, heart disease, diabetes to name a few. Stop tricking your body and just treat your body right. I am not perfect myself — when the (probably processed) cookies are out, I will eat them. I am not preaching perfection. I’m just saying do yourself a favor, stop stressing about how many calories are in your Snackwells cookie, eat a peach or two and take a walk outside. All you can do is your best and no one’s best is perfect. Trickery is not needed!
OK. Rant done.
Come back tomorrow or maybe early next week to hear about the very strange Counting Crows/not really Counting Crows concert I went to on Tuesday night. And see pictures. And maybe see videos if I can figure out how to put them up.
And click here if you want to contribute to my fundraising efforts for the World Trade Center Run to Remember. That is a 5K race I am running (my first!) on September 6. The proceeds I raise go to a charity I selected called the September 11th Families Association.
Jen, a priorfatgirl
August 27, 2009 at 1:11 pm (15 years ago)I like your rants. Mostly because it is exactly the rant in my head which I always seem to forget to post.
I totally agree, wouldn’t it make sense for PR companies to actually pay attention to the blog site they are asking for review on? I mean, what if the product is completely against what the blog is about, and they do get the blog writer to write the review anyways and it’s not even being posted for the right audience? Wasted time, money, resources & energy!
Jen
August 27, 2009 at 1:19 pm (15 years ago)The ignorance of that company just shows how it branches into it’s equally ignorant customers. Let’s just shove them into a corner and rely on survival of the fittest method.
Diana (Soap & Chocolate)
August 27, 2009 at 1:27 pm (15 years ago)OMG that must have been so annoying! Obviously not reading a word you write, either on the blog or in an email. I can relate–we have issues with that kind of thing in my office, and that’s not even with people trying to promote their product!
caitlin
August 27, 2009 at 1:34 pm (15 years ago)i just ignore emails like that. dont even bother to reply.
Olga
August 27, 2009 at 6:40 pm (15 years ago)OMG Dori! I got the EXACT same email and the EXACT same response! I’m pissed as well. Thanks for writing about this!
Kelly Turner
August 27, 2009 at 10:04 pm (15 years ago)haha i think i know EXACTLY what you are talking about and had the exact same reaction. i hate that everyone assumes if you work out you are trying to lose weight. I get “why are you here?” comments at the gym all the time. um, really? seriously?
it just goes to show that no one at that company knows anything about a healthy lifestyle
Megzz @ Megzz Wins At Life
August 28, 2009 at 8:28 am (15 years ago)Dori… I You are so right when you talk about programs like that.. they should first see what kind of blog it is before they go and send all these e-mails..
Michelle @ Find Your Balance
August 28, 2009 at 9:12 am (15 years ago)Oh wow, yeah, I get those a lot. People are like, “Since you have promoted yogurt in the past on your blog, would you like to share our new pro-biotic blah blah blah” and I’m like, man, I’ve NEVER talked about yogurt. And your yogurt is full of sugar and growth hormones so no thanks.
haha rant over for me too now 🙂
melissa
August 28, 2009 at 10:31 am (15 years ago)great post. You are so right about processed food.
A@ Please Don't Eat Me!
August 29, 2009 at 9:45 am (15 years ago)WOW! people have nerve!! i guess they are just trying to get the “word” out there about their product.
i will admit, i took diet pills at some point in my life and yea they worked! but i was also a miserable BITCH all the time : )
when i stopped taking them i didnt gain too much weight back, but i had horrible withdrawl symptoms.. i do NOT recommend anything .. nothing for “diet” purposes beyond clean eating, working out and maybe some green tea ; )
his explanation
March 9, 2016 at 4:20 pm (9 years ago)May I simply say what a comfort to uncover someone that actually understands what they’re discussing over the internet. You certainly realize how to bring a problem to light and make it important. A lot more people have to read this and understand this side of your story. I was surprised that you are not more popular because you certainly possess the gift.|